This time around I thought I would do something a little different. I sent the email out and since this person likes cheesecake so much, I asked if everyone would be willing to donate $1-2 each so I can get a big cheesecake for them and us to share. I did mention it was optional of course, but to let me know either way. Half of the people responded and donated, the other half did not respond and did not donate.
Should I present the gift of cheesecake to this person as if it was from the whole group, or should I attach a little card note saying the cheesecake was from the people that donated?