Chérie (lutine) wrote in thequestionclub,
Chérie
lutine
thequestionclub

Can anyone help me with a car mechanical question?

My car is a 2009, I've owned it for two years. It was previously a rental car. I've put approximately 3k miles on it each year I've had it and I get the oil changed once a year. It's about due for it again - it's been less than the recommended miles, but it's been a full year since the last one.

I took it in to the dealership for an unrelated problem, and the mechanic told me that he noticed my engine was totally full of sludge because I either don't change the oil enough, or possibly it was like that before I bought it. He told me that I could try to have the engine flushed but he didn't think that would really help, and he said that in his opinion, this sludge was going to cause serious engine problems which would not be covered by my warranty because it was due to lack of maintenance. His advice was to trade the car in - but of course, he works for a car dealership so I didn't necessarily want to take his word for it.

I called my dad (he lives in another state so he can't look at the car) and he said that the mechanic was full of crap. He said that a) You can't tell if there's sludge in the engine without taking the engine apart, and b) It's impossible to build up so much sludge that it would damage the engine if the car is only 3 or 4 years old, even if it wasn't maintained at all before I bought it. He told me to just get the oil changed like normal and forget what that guy said.

So who should I believe?? I don't particularly want to trade the car in (especially if there's nothing really wrong with it and the mechanic was lying), but I don't want to risk my car having some serious mechanical problem that isn't going to be covered by my warranty! Help?
Subscribe

  • New homeowner surprises

    So far in my new townhouse I have discovered a subfloor structure that evokes this response in every handy/building contractor who's visited:…

  • RIP Yahoo!Answers Mega Quiz

    One of the last weird, wild places on the Internet is going away. Yahoo! is shuttering Answers after almost two decades of service. The answers were…

  • would you go?

    (this is a question I found online in another group, what are your thoughts? mine in the comments) I have a dilemma...One of my best friends…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Comments allowed for members only

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 23 comments

  • New homeowner surprises

    So far in my new townhouse I have discovered a subfloor structure that evokes this response in every handy/building contractor who's visited:…

  • RIP Yahoo!Answers Mega Quiz

    One of the last weird, wild places on the Internet is going away. Yahoo! is shuttering Answers after almost two decades of service. The answers were…

  • would you go?

    (this is a question I found online in another group, what are your thoughts? mine in the comments) I have a dilemma...One of my best friends…