Note: Both resorts are the same cost for lodging/all inclusive packages and include the same activitise.
-Go to a Club Med resort in Turks & Caicos.
pros: Gorgeous, safe island. Beautiful resort. You know some of the people who work there well enough that you've seen them in the US since leaving T&C. No kids.
cons: 2x as expensive for airfare as the below option; you've already been there. Older resort than option #2.
-Go to a Club Med resort in Cancun, Mexico.
pros: airfare is way cheap, you've never been there, it's a newer resort.
cons: family-friendly (we don't have kids), Mexico is on a safety advisory so we likely would not feel safe leaving the resort.